I recently visited this place, and I have to say, it’s truly a hidden gem when it comes to pancakes! Although I come to Princeton often, this was my first time here, and I’m so glad I finally made it. It was already 8:30 PM when I arrived, so I decided to keep it simple and ordered just pancakes. However, I was amazed by the sheer variety they offer — so many different types of pancakes to choose from!
I ended up ordering two kinds: the plain pancakes and the coconut banana rum pancakes. Let me tell you, both were absolutely delicious. The plain pancakes were perfect on their own — fluffy, light, and just the right amount of sweetness. But the coconut banana rum pancakes were truly exceptional! The flavors blended together so well, with the coconut adding a nice tropical touch, the banana providing a bit of natural sweetness, and the rum giving it a unique twist. It was a perfect combination.
The service was also great. Our server was friendly, polite, and attentive, which made the experience even better. I will definitely be coming back, not only to enjoy those amazing pancakes again but also to try the many other varieties they have on the menu. This place is now on my must-visit list every time I’m in Princeton!
Jane C
-
December 04, 2024
PJ's Pancake House seems to be a pillar of this part of Jersey. We were only in Princeton for the weekend and asked around for a few must-eat spots, and it seemed that PJ's Pancake House came up more than a few times. We were heartened by the line that was already forming at its doors on a Sunday morning, knowing that where there's a line, good food awaits.
(And for those who disdain a queue, rest assured, the line moves fast, mainly because the servers and line cooks move around with frightening efficiency).
The pancakes are well worth the rave. We got two of their pecan pancakes, and they neared perfection in their fluffiness, taste, and the sheer density of pecans that were tossed into the batter. I also ordered some scrambled eggs and bacon on the side, which were just fine.
My husband went somewhat rogue with the shakshuka, which is a tomato-based stew with poached eggs. It's served with several crusty pieces of bread, and it's hard to understate how sexily the crostini skated through that thick, savory gravy and egg yolk. If we had any complaints, it was a little saltier than we would've liked.
Those waiting in line are often given a choice - counter seats open up faster, but table seats are more comfortable. We opted to grab seats at a counter, and it was fun to watch the dizzying action in the kitchen and around the service stations.
Gabrielle Garduno
-
August 26, 2024
The food was fresh and came out surprisingly fast. The service was great and the place had good AC. It can get crowded on the weekends (especially the first half of the day), so be aware. I decided to try the Shakshuka, which I’ve never had before and loved it. I even went back the following day to get it again. I highly recommend.
anshul agarwal
-
September 10, 2024
Best Pancakes in the area. Soft fluffy, in so many varieties and so reasonably priced. I tried their special fig cream pancakes and it was yummy fig’s sweetness was broken by creams sourness … so yummy
Es j k
-
June 16, 2024
There’s a reason why they have been a staple in Princeton for decades
Best pancake menu and execution is spot on. My favorites are the Rum Coconut and the Blueberry pancakes. Great coffee too
I highly recommend PJ’s on Nassau Street
I recently visited this place, and I have to say, it’s truly a hidden gem when it comes to pancakes! Although I come to Princeton often, this was my first time here, and I’m so glad I finally made it. It was already 8:30 PM when I arrived, so I decided to keep it simple and ordered just pancakes. However, I was amazed by the sheer variety they offer — so many different types of pancakes to choose from! I ended up ordering two kinds: the plain pancakes and the coconut banana rum pancakes. Let me tell you, both were absolutely delicious. The plain pancakes were perfect on their own — fluffy, light, and just the right amount of sweetness. But the coconut banana rum pancakes were truly exceptional! The flavors blended together so well, with the coconut adding a nice tropical touch, the banana providing a bit of natural sweetness, and the rum giving it a unique twist. It was a perfect combination. The service was also great. Our server was friendly, polite, and attentive, which made the experience even better. I will definitely be coming back, not only to enjoy those amazing pancakes again but also to try the many other varieties they have on the menu. This place is now on my must-visit list every time I’m in Princeton!
PJ's Pancake House seems to be a pillar of this part of Jersey. We were only in Princeton for the weekend and asked around for a few must-eat spots, and it seemed that PJ's Pancake House came up more than a few times. We were heartened by the line that was already forming at its doors on a Sunday morning, knowing that where there's a line, good food awaits. (And for those who disdain a queue, rest assured, the line moves fast, mainly because the servers and line cooks move around with frightening efficiency). The pancakes are well worth the rave. We got two of their pecan pancakes, and they neared perfection in their fluffiness, taste, and the sheer density of pecans that were tossed into the batter. I also ordered some scrambled eggs and bacon on the side, which were just fine. My husband went somewhat rogue with the shakshuka, which is a tomato-based stew with poached eggs. It's served with several crusty pieces of bread, and it's hard to understate how sexily the crostini skated through that thick, savory gravy and egg yolk. If we had any complaints, it was a little saltier than we would've liked. Those waiting in line are often given a choice - counter seats open up faster, but table seats are more comfortable. We opted to grab seats at a counter, and it was fun to watch the dizzying action in the kitchen and around the service stations.
The food was fresh and came out surprisingly fast. The service was great and the place had good AC. It can get crowded on the weekends (especially the first half of the day), so be aware. I decided to try the Shakshuka, which I’ve never had before and loved it. I even went back the following day to get it again. I highly recommend.
Best Pancakes in the area. Soft fluffy, in so many varieties and so reasonably priced. I tried their special fig cream pancakes and it was yummy fig’s sweetness was broken by creams sourness … so yummy
There’s a reason why they have been a staple in Princeton for decades Best pancake menu and execution is spot on. My favorites are the Rum Coconut and the Blueberry pancakes. Great coffee too I highly recommend PJ’s on Nassau Street