This place definitely met the high expectations I went in with. I got their most popular whole hoagie (the Sanchez) for a total of $18 with tax. It came with mozzarella sticks, fries, chicken cutlet pieces, and their "Sanchez" sauce. It was humongous and was extremely filling and delicious. Every bite was so good! My friend got their cheesesteak and it was also amazing. I am definitely coming back to this Nassau Street staple.
Taylor G
-
February 04, 2025
Great place to have a cheat day. One of the few places you can consistently look forward to. Fat sandwiches are always on point, and their recipes are uniquely satisfying. Favorite is the sanchez and some buffalo fries. Their whole menu is good! As someone who exercises frequently, it's the only thing stopping me from finding excuses to come here even more consistently. Definitely worth a try, you probably won't regret it! Nice to eat and hangout in downtown Princeton.
Laila Wilson
-
January 21, 2025
It is a cute local store / sandwich shop. My cousin from Cali heard about it (I live in NJ) and had it on his "places". I was not disappointed that we stopped here before heading to the airport.
The bread was crusty, meat fresh and sliced super thin, and the veggies were crisp. I love how you can customize your order with ease and the lady at the counter was super friendly.
John K
-
May 31, 2024
The hoagie is average at best, Wawa may even have them beat and I am not a Wawa fan. I am sure it is a quick bite for college students in the area but I wouldn't consider this to be a great hoagie by any stretch of the imagination. The meat looks thick and could even be pre-sliced.
I am fairly certain that my wife and I both had a minor case of food poisoning after both having shared an Italian hoagie.
perle75nyc
-
May 11, 2024
It's not very special, but it's definitely a delicious sandwich that sticks to the basics. All ingredients were fresh. The store was clean. The staff were friendly.
This place definitely met the high expectations I went in with. I got their most popular whole hoagie (the Sanchez) for a total of $18 with tax. It came with mozzarella sticks, fries, chicken cutlet pieces, and their "Sanchez" sauce. It was humongous and was extremely filling and delicious. Every bite was so good! My friend got their cheesesteak and it was also amazing. I am definitely coming back to this Nassau Street staple.
Great place to have a cheat day. One of the few places you can consistently look forward to. Fat sandwiches are always on point, and their recipes are uniquely satisfying. Favorite is the sanchez and some buffalo fries. Their whole menu is good! As someone who exercises frequently, it's the only thing stopping me from finding excuses to come here even more consistently. Definitely worth a try, you probably won't regret it! Nice to eat and hangout in downtown Princeton.
It is a cute local store / sandwich shop. My cousin from Cali heard about it (I live in NJ) and had it on his "places". I was not disappointed that we stopped here before heading to the airport. The bread was crusty, meat fresh and sliced super thin, and the veggies were crisp. I love how you can customize your order with ease and the lady at the counter was super friendly.
The hoagie is average at best, Wawa may even have them beat and I am not a Wawa fan. I am sure it is a quick bite for college students in the area but I wouldn't consider this to be a great hoagie by any stretch of the imagination. The meat looks thick and could even be pre-sliced. I am fairly certain that my wife and I both had a minor case of food poisoning after both having shared an Italian hoagie.
It's not very special, but it's definitely a delicious sandwich that sticks to the basics. All ingredients were fresh. The store was clean. The staff were friendly.